Leads Falling Through the Cracks Between Your Tools? How We Plugged the Hole for Johnathan Bender Productions

Johnathan Bender Productions was running sales funnels across two different email platforms, Ontraport and AWeber. That's not unusual. Plenty of businesses end up with two systems doing similar jobs, usually because one was there first and the other was added for a specific campaign.

The problem was what had to happen every time someone new registered.

Each registration had to go to the right platform, into the right sequence, with the right tracking attached so the team knew where that person came from. And all of that was being done by hand.

What happens when leads are moved by hand?

When people are manually managing lists across multiple platforms, things get missed. Not because the team is careless, but because a manual process depends on someone remembering every step, every time, without a single slip.

So leads were landing in the wrong sequences. Tracking was breaking along the way, which meant nobody could be sure which campaign had actually brought someone in. And every new campaign needed someone to sit and babysit the process to make sure it worked.

It was slow, it was error-prone, and it couldn't grow with the business. The more campaigns they ran, the more chances there were for a lead to get lost.

How we plugged the hole

We built a piece of middleware, which is just a small system that sits between the tools and does the moving for you. Every registration now went automatically to the right platform, into the right place, with its tracking information still intact.

Nobody had to copy anything. Nobody had to remember which list a new lead belonged on. And launching a new campaign no longer meant setting up a babysitter.

The results were exactly what you'd want. Tracking attribution was accurate across every funnel. The manual routing work disappeared entirely. Campaigns launched faster because there was no setup bottleneck, and the system was ready to handle more volume as the business grew.

Where are the cracks in a service business?

You might not be running two email platforms, but almost every service business has a few places where leads get passed along by hand.

Think about the path a new client takes. They fill out a form on your website, call your office, message you on social media, or get referred by a partner. Then somebody has to get that information into your booking system or CRM, send a follow-up, and maybe tag where they came from.

Every one of those steps is a place where a lead can quietly disappear. The form submission sits in an inbox nobody checks over the weekend. The phone inquiry gets written on a sticky note. The referral never gets tagged, so the partner who sent it never gets credit.

You'll rarely notice a single lost lead. That's what makes it expensive. It shows up as a slow month, a referral partner who stops sending people, or marketing that seems to work less than it should.

How do you know if you're losing leads?

Start by following one lead from the very first contact to the moment they book or buy. Write down every place that information has to move, and who or what moves it.

Then look for three warning signs. Anywhere a person has to copy information from one tool into another is a crack. Anywhere a lead can come in without anyone being notified is a crack. And anywhere the information about where the lead came from gets dropped along the way is a crack, because that's how your numbers stop matching reality.

If you find more than one or two of those, you're almost certainly losing leads you never knew you had.

How to close the gaps

Frequently asked questions